Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

key-lime ice cream with chunks of Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie, layered with frozen meringue

"The key lime pie was unbelievable! " — Amanda U.

Sourcing Partners:

Gimme S'More

Gimme S'More

graham cracker ice cream with toasted Baked marshmallows and chocolate chunks

"MilkMade has definitely succeeded in taking this ever-popular combination of campfire flavors to an entirely new level of epicurean deliciousness." — Margaret K.

Sourcing Partners:

Flavors of the Month: June 2011

Key Lime Pie in a Pint

Key-limes, by name, are obviously not local. But sometimes flavor overpowers function, and we have to source our ingredients elsewhere. Key Lime Pie is one of those overpowering flavors that we just HAD to share with you. We've teamed up with Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Red Hook to bring you authenticity in a pint - fresh key lime ice cream, a few bits of Steve's Key Lime Pie, all layered with our homemade frozen meringue. You'll never find another pint like it.

Gimme S'More

With summer on its way, we're excited to head to the mountains (when we're not at the beach, or the kitchen, or your doorstep, that is). Thus inspired, we've created the best rendition of a s'more you've ever had - a creamy graham cracker ice cream, fire roasted marshmallows made by Red Hook based bakery, Baked, and chocolate chunks from our favorite brothers in Williamsburg, Mast Brothers Chocolate. It's creamy, it's marshmallowey, and it has a chocolatey crunch. If your tastes are anything like ours, this one will leave you saying GIMME S'MORE.

Past Flavors: 2012

Semifreddo / Twelve Grapes

Raven Red Velvet / Salted Caramel

Follow the Rainbow / German Chocolate Cake

Mint Chocolate Cookie / Carrot Cake

Poutpourri / Honey-Roasted Honeycomb

Tom Collins / Grady's Manhattan

Rock Rock Rockaway Road / Rumble in Brighton

Scratch Root Beer Float / Big Stick

Dirty Banana / Blueberry Buckle

Monster Mash / Two Snaps and a Hay

The Audacity of Hops / No Apologies

The Best Worst Holiday Gift / The Last Pint


Outside of NYC? Join the waitlist today.

Say Hi!