Monster Mash

Monster Mash

concord grape ice cream with a peanut butter swirl, marshmallows, graham, and chocolate chips

"Monster Mash for the kid in me @milkmadescream. Concord grape ice cream with a peanut butter swirl, marshmallows, graham, and chocolate chips. Absolute heaven." — Aleesha P.

"The ice cream was unbelievably good and I'm embarrassed to say how much of it I ate last night... and again this morning..." — Rebecca R.

Sourcing Partners:

Two Snaps and a Hay

Two Snaps and a Hay

hay ice cream with chunks of gingersnaps

"this ice cream tasted just like Autumn" — Emma C.

Sourcing Partners:

Flavors of the Month: October 2012

They Did the Mash

All Hallows Eve brings out the (big) kid in us. And this 'scream is the embodiment of that - it's a kid's dream come true, re-crafted for your more refined palate. We started with our annual concord grape 'scream, and then went to town with the best in town. We mixed in fluffy marshmallows from Baked, crunchy graham crackers, intense chocolate chips from the Brothers Mast, and topped it all off with a peanut butter swirl made with Saratoga Peanut Butter's Plain Jane. It's totally a graveyard smash.

Hay Now

Oh no we didn't (yes we did). We give two snaps up, and a big hey for this month's 'scream. Inspired by apple cider, pumpkin picking and hay rides, this 'scream is made out of, well, hay. Yes literally. (It's delicious, we promise). The hay ice cream is mixed with chunks of soft gingersnaps from Baking for Good. Hay now.

Past Flavors: 2015

Namaste / Citrus Paradisi

Brooklyn Ambrosia / Black Hearts Party, Pt Deux

Winter's Emollient / Five Dollar Toast

THE Cookie Dough Pint / THE Macaroon Pint

Tim Tam Slam / Open Sesame

June Gloom / Midsummer Night's 'Scream

Torched S'more / SBPB

Sarsaparilla Sour / Cactus Cooler

Lime in the Coconut / Tomato Tomato

Harvest Moon / Rosemary's Baby

Cobbler Hill / Leftovers

Partridge in a Pear Tree / Gløgg


Outside of NYC? Join the waitlist today.

Say Hi!